DALLAS — Weeding out “unfit” from “fit” people was a common medical practice in Nazi Germany.
The practice was just as common in the United States at one point, Stacy Gallin said Friday at Misericordia University.
Gallin, the founder of the Maimonides Institute for Medicine, Ethics and the Holocaust in Freehold, N.J., delivered a presentation entitled “Commemorating the 70th anniversary of the Doctors’ Trials and the Nuremberg Code: What Have We learned?” at the university.
The presentation was part of a “Deadly Medicine” speaker series that coincides with the “Deadly Medicine: Creating the Master Race” exhibit in the Pauly Friedman Art Gallery in the Sandy and Marlene Insalaco Hall.
Gallin provided a look back at the 1930s to show how medical care shifted its focus from treating the individual to treating societal problems, such as mental health issues and physical defects as illnesses resulting in death to men, women and children.
The concept was known as eugenics, the science of eliminating physical and mental faults to breed desirable traits, and rose to popularity worldwide with the United States leading the way, she said.
“It is a very easy theory to buy into,” Gallin said. “It is the idea of creating a better society by improving human heredity. You breed horses and dogs, why not people?”
The United States began sterilizing people before Germany to ensure positive human characteristics would be carried through to the next generation, she said.
“Germany took lessons from us,” Gallin said.
Interest in eugenics grew in Germany.
After World War I, there was a declining birth rate among the “better, more fit productive class,” she said. The birth rate among the “physically and mentally unfit,” rose, Gallin said.
The fear was the “unfit” would doom the German nation, she said.
“If someone had a physical disability that meant they couldn’t do things to benefit society, then, why have them around?” Gallin said. “This is an important paradigm shift from caring for the individual to caring for society.”
At this time, people deemed “unfit” were not viewed as individuals, but as part of the whole, Gallin said. Dehumanization of groups of people began to set in.
“These laws and policies were seen as public health measures” to benefit the whole society, she said.
During the Holocaust, doctors committed egregious violations of ethics.
A physician would determine whether a child would live or die by a questionnaire, she said.
“Not even meeting the child,” Gallin said. “Just a piece of paper and write a plus or minus on the top that decided the fate of a child.”
Holocaust doctors falsified death certificates to state a child died of natural causes when the physician had actually killed the child, she said.
The Holocaust was the only medically sanctioned genocide, but is used today as a framework to study other instances, Gallin said.
“The ability of the medical community to abuse that power runs through all medical history,” she said. “We need to remember the past to protect the future,” Gallin said.
